Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Differently

I can't find the exact quote, but President Bush said yesterday about the "Mission Accomplished" banner on the aircraft carrier that it was a mistake. "We tried to say something differently," he said, "but it had a different effect."  There's nothing grammatically incorrect in that statement, but it got me thinking about what he must have meant.

"Differently" is an adverb, so in this case it modifies the verb "say." Thus he must mean that he meant to say something in a different way. By "something" I don't think he meant the word "something" so there is some unstated message that he wanted to give in a way that differed from . . . what? Did he mean that he had already been expressing this unmentioned thought, and now he chose the banner as a different way of expressing it?

Perhaps he meant "something" in the sense of "I don't really care which thing." Perhaps he felt that he had been in a rut, using a fixed means of expression for all his utterances, and he wanted to say something -- anything -- differently to break the monotony.

We get a hint from the fact that he added that it had a different effect. Different from what? He didn't say, but he added that it gave the wrong message.

I suppose he's just trying to say, "I made a mistake, but there was an innocent reason for it."  So far, he hasn't articulated the innocent reason in a way that I can understand.